Missing in Mississippi: Marguerite Mayden, Harrison County

Marguerite Mayden, Harrison County

There was no record of Marguerite “Peggy” Mayden’s blood type when she went missing on April 30, 1980, as she had lived in Panama for a large part of her life. 

DNA technology was minimal, if it existed at all, so when her vehicle was found the next day with a large amount of blood in the trunk, there was no way for investigators to know if that blood, and the blood found all throughout Mayden’s home, was hers. 

On the night she disappeared, Mayden had been at her next-door neighbor’s home for a gathering and then left to walk to her house to cook a hamburger. That was the last time she was reported as seen alive.

Mayden, who was 60 at the time of her disappearance, lived alone in Ancient Oaks, an upper-class neighborhood in Biloxi. The widow of an Air Force Colonel, she was an avid golfer at the time of her disappearance and had played the sport competitively since at least the 1960s. 

A neighbor who noticed she hadn’t seen her for a couple of days went over to check on her, finding blood on the floor and cabinets in the kitchen, as well as a blood trail leading from the kitchen, through the living room and dining room, and into a bathroom at the rear of the home. She feared the worst and called 911.

Police arrived on scene and shortly thereafter it was clear that Mayden’s pit bull, Macho, and her 197 Buick Riviera were also missing.

The vehicle was found at the Holiday Inn on Highway 90 in Biloxi with a large blood stain in the trunk of the vehicle. Witnesses said that they witnessed a man park the car there, get out, and walk away from the hotel. Several days later, Macho was found safe in north Gulfport, about 15 miles from Mayden’s home, when he wandered up to a home. The homeowner had read his description and called police.

There had been dog hair in the trunk, leading police to think Macho had been in the trunk at one point, but he showed no signs of having been injured.

It appeared that there was a bitter struggle in Mayden’s kitchen, as blood was found on the floor and the cabinets. One of the cabinets was even cracked, and police surmised her head had been smashed into it so hard that it cracked the cabinet door.

Bloody handprints were found near the bedroom and the bathroom, and another blood trail from the bathroom back to the kitchen. Authorities said at the time that they believe that the suspect carried Mayden from the kitchen to the bathroom to clean her up. It also appeared that they had attempted to clean up the crime scene.

Two impressions of a size 10 rubber-soled running shoe were left on the linoleum in the kitchen, and at the time, authorities said they believed there could have been two suspects. There was evidence that someone had tried to clean parts of the scene, and a table had been put back into place after the struggle, and police said that attention to detail probably belonged to a woman.

There were all sorts of false leads at the time, such as an anonymous tip that sent police searching sink holes on I-10, and a friend who said she heard Peggy calling to her at Mardi Gras but didn’t see her. Another tip said she was at the Atlanta airport, but it was a case of mistaken identity. Authorities also looked into rumors that some of her friends had been involved in drug trafficking, but nothing panned out.

Police said the case was particularly tough because there was no forced entry, nothing stolen, and no evidence pointing to a motive. The amount of blood, however, led police to believe Mayden was the victim of a homicide. Her body has never been located.

Peggy Mayden was 5’3″ tall, and around 125 Lbs. She had blonde hair and green eyes.

If you know anything about this case, please call the Biloxi Police Department at 228-435-6112.

share it

Latest News